RestaurantSitti’s Table
Wagyu Hot Beef Sandwich on artisanal bread; tender brisket with Dijon aioli and onion jam.

West Yellowstone's Wild West Pizzeria & Saloon blends a casual Italian-American menu with a Western saloon vibe. The dining room is family-friendly, decorated with bison head mounts, coyote skins, and Native art; the saloon side hosts live music on select nights. Service is table service in the dining area, while the saloon operates separately. Signature pies include the Butch Cassidy Pizzaβsmoky pulled pork, barbecue sauce, baked beans, and red onionsβand the Doc Holiday Pizza, a veggie-...
Skip the generic pepperoni pie, get the Butch Cassidy pizza. For beer, order a local draft.
This is West Yellowstone post-hike HQ. It is loud, lively, and welcoming to families; bring your appetite and your dancing shoes for the saloon nights.
The sidewalk line grows on weekends; join the online waitlist to secure a table and cut the wait; arrive by 11:30 AM or after 6 PM for shorter waits.
EAT HERE IF: Families with kids, pizza lovers, live music fans. SKIP IF: You need a quick, quiet meal during peak hours.
Pancho Villa taco pizza and Butch Cassidy BBQ pizza made with Wheat Montana dough
Signature Dishes: Butch Cassidy pizza, Annie Oakley Margarita, Blazing Saddle, Butch Cassidy calzone, Diablo Wings
Butch Cassidy pizza, Annie Oakley Margarita, Butch Cassidy calzone
Weekdays 11:30 AMβ2:00 PM for a calmer bite; after 6:00 PM for dinner; weekends are the busiest.
Quiet, ultra-fast meals or formal dining experiences
Family dining area; large calzones; kid-friendly options
Pizza crust is blistered and bold with generous cheese; toppings feel substantial and regional flair shows in Butch Cassidy and Pancho Villa options. Calzones deliver a shareable, hearty bite, and wings offer heat with a milder alternative. The vibe blends family dining with a lively saloonβplan for waits on weekends.
Address
14 Madison Ave, West Yellowstone, MT 59758, USA
To Park Center
approximately 27 miles from park entrance
Street parking and nearby public lots in West Yellowstone
Based on 4314 Google reviews
Based on 4314 guest reviews
" Pizza crust is blistered and bold with generous cheese; toppings feel substantial and regional flair shows in Butch Cassidy and Pancho Villa options. Calzones deliver a shareable, hearty bite, and wings offer heat with a milder alternative. The vibe blends family dining with a lively saloonβplan for waits on weekends."
Thomas B
Great location, great food and service and we were lucky to get there before the evening rush hour. It is worth the visit if you are ever in town. FYI - sorry about the food photos, the lasagna was so good I forgot the photo until it was almost gone, I was also hungry at the time.
Saysha Reyes
We loved the Wild West names of the pizzas, and the food was delicious. We tried the Doc Holliday and the Wild West pizzas, along with the cheesy bread sticks and mac and cheese. It looks like a bar (there is one inside, too), and the pizza was much higher quality than we expected. Plus I've never had broccoli on pizza and it was a total win. I almost didn't get a picture in time!
Alice Weaver
In the mood for pizza? This is a great place to satisfy that craving! Not only do they have pizza, they also have sandwiches and various pastas! We decided on the Wild West Supreme and BYO pepperoni and olive. Both pizzas tasted great! We loved that they have a thin, crispy crust. The mixed green salad was cold, just the right portion. Don't pass up on the Sis' Breadsticks. Service was quick. This place gets busy, so bring a dose of patience if you have to wait to be seated
Showing 3 of 4314 reviews
Yes. Gluten-free pizza bases and gluten-free beer are available; the crust can be crispy and holds toppings well.
Live music happens regularly; check the schedule for bands and karaoke nights.
Walk-in only; you can join a remote waitlist online to secure seating during busy times.
Takeout is available via a takeout express option, though a dedicated express location was noted as closed until summer 2026; delivery is not listed as available.
Standouts include Butch Cassidy pizza (BBQ pork, red onions), Pancho Villa taco pizza, Annie Oakley Margarita, and large Butch Cassidy calzones.
6 listings
Information is compiled from official sources, verified traveler reviews, and editorial research. Learn how YourNPGuide works β
Notifications