
Thin NJ-style crust with a crisp edge and a solid chew, crowned by premium toppings that stay flavorful from slice to slice. The Animal Pizza delivers bold toppings and a lively finish, while Jersey Buns grip garlic and olive oil with mozzarella driving the bite. Gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese are available, and the kitchen nearly makes everything in-house. It’s a casual, family-friendly joint that can get loud, especially near peak hours on weekends.
Authentic New Jersey style pies and Jersey Buns
Signature Dishes: Authentic New Jersey-Style Pies; Animal Pizza; Jersey Buns
Animal Pizza, Jersey Buns, Caprese Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Weekdays during off-peak hours, e.g., 11:00-12:30 or 1:30-3:00; avoid Saturday lunch rush.
Quiet, hushed, upscale dining experiences
Kid-friendly; casual; dog-friendly patio; lively atmosphere
No detailed accessibility data available; space includes a sit-down dining room and an outdoor patio; confirm ADA ramps/restrooms as needed.
Increased parking at the new US 93 South location.
Based on 1533 Google reviews
Peony Blossom
I've been here twice. I tried the Animal pizza the first time and it was amazing. The second time I decided to try the Garbage Can and the Classic. They were also really tasty but the Animal is the one I'd recommend. It's very flavorful. I also tried the jersey rolls and the meatballs. I'd pass on those next time and stick to pizza or maybe a sandwich. I will definitely go back. The young girl waitressing could use some help so she doesn't have to juggle so much. The atmosphere is lacking cohesiveness and needs some more fun decor. Maybe ownership will keep investing in the dining area inside and out. The pizza is so good that I won't dock any stars for that so that others can find a yummy pizza too! Also, please fix the paper towel dispenser in the restroom.
Jacqulyn Lynch
Jersey boys is the best pizza in the Valley! We come from New Jersey originally, so finding pizza that makes us just as happy is hard work. I can tell you this is equally as good (if not better) than some of our local spots back home that are considered the best of the best. The new location is awesome, all the workers are as well!
Kaitley Cowan
Came here for some good pizza after reading good reviews for here. But it was a letdown. The atmosphere here is not great. Music was extremely loud, and it wasn't very good. The food was okay. I got the gluten-free pizza with dairy free cheese, and the pizza was burnt. The cheese they used was not very good. There were flies everywhere, too. Won't be back.
Showing 3 of 1533 reviews
Yes, gluten-free crusts are available, including a dedicated gluten-free oven to prevent cross-contact.
Yes, vegan cheese is available.
Yes, takeout and take-and-bake options are available.
Yes, the outdoor patio is dog-friendly.
It can be loud at times, especially with music and crowds; still, it remains family-friendly.
Yes, there is increased parking at the new US 93 South location.
Information is compiled from official sources, verified traveler reviews, and editorial research. Learn how YourNPGuide works →